Challenging the Status Quo
The Value and meaning of Critical Criminology & Critical practice
〰️
The Value and meaning of Critical Criminology & Critical practice 〰️
What is critical criminology?
Critical criminology is a broad and evolving field that challenges mainstream criminology by examining how power, inequality, and social structures shape crime and justice. Lacking a single definition, it encompasses diverse perspectives, methodologies, and ideologies. As DeKeseredy and Dragiewicz (2012:1) note,
"The definition of critical criminology is subject to much debate and there is no widely accepted precise formulation."
Emerging in response to traditional theories, it critiques the legal system, state power, and corporate crime, advocating for a more just and equitable society.
What is critical practice?
Critical practice is the application of critical criminological theories to real-world justice issues, aiming to challenge power structures, address systemic inequalities, and promote alternative approaches to crime control (DeKeseredy & Dragiewicz, 2012). It emphasises restorative justice, prison reform, and community-based interventions over punitive measures, advocating for policies that tackle the root causes of crime, such as poverty and discrimination (Carrington & Pereira, 2009). Through activism, policy change, and alternative justice models, critical practice seeks to create a more equitable and just legal system.
Why is critical criminology & practice important?
1. Challenges Traditional Crime Narratives
Traditional criminology often focuses on individual responsibility and punitive justice, overlooking systemic factors like poverty, racism, and political power.
Critical criminology reframes crime as a product of social structures and inequalities, leading to more comprehensive and just solutions (DeKeseredy & Dragiewicz, 2012).
2. Exposes Power and Inequality in the Criminal Justice System
The justice system disproportionately targets marginalised groups (e.g., racial minorities, the poor, LGBTQ+ individuals).
Critical criminology highlights issues such as racial profiling, sentencing disparities, and mass incarceration, pushing for reforms to address these injustices (Carrington & Pereira, 2009).
3. Promotes Restorative and Community-Based Justice
Instead of focusing solely on punishment, critical practice advocates for restorative justice, where offenders and victims work toward healing and rehabilitation.
Alternative approaches, such as community-led crime prevention programs, have been shown to be more effective in reducing reoffending (Zehr, 2002).
4. Addresses Corporate and State Crime
Traditional criminology often neglects white-collar crime, state violence, and corporate misconduct, despite their significant societal harm.
Critical criminology calls for greater accountability for powerful actors, ensuring justice applies to all levels of society (Tombs & Whyte, 2010).
5. Influences Policy and Social Change
Critical criminological perspectives have shaped real-world policy changes, including:
Drug decriminalisation (e.g., Portugal’s harm reduction approach).
Prison reform (e.g., Scandinavian rehabilitative models).
Police accountability movements (e.g., Black Lives Matter).
By advocating for evidence-based, humane policies, critical practice contributes to a fairer and more effective justice system.
Purpose of the blog post
The purpose of this blog post is to explore the meaning and value of critical criminology and critical practice. It aims to highlight how critical criminology challenges traditional understandings of crime by focusing on power, inequality, and social context. The post also examines how critical practice translates these theories into real-world applications, such as restorative justice and community-based interventions. Ultimately, it encourages readers to consider more equitable and transformative approaches to justice.
